10. Making It Global
A mechanism that stops at a border relocates the risk instead of reducing it. What adoption would actually have to look like, and what it would still fail to reach.
11. Compare and Contrast
How this proposal stacks up against the other things people suggest, including on the axes where it loses badly.
Is the Quiet World Stable?
This site's central line is that shifting the Nash equilibrium is easier than solving alignment. It describes the equilibrium it wants to leave in detail and the one it would arrive at almost not at all. Four players, checked one at a time for a profitable unilateral deviation.
Overlapping Jurisdictions Are a Feature
What this proposal asks for is not a world government. It is one more overlapping legal order in a life that already contains several, and the rigorous case for that is about credible commitment, not about liberty.
Pacing Is a Setting on a Dial
Anthropic's CEO now says frontier AI has to be slowed, and he has a three-step plan to do it. I agree with where he's going and disagree with the route in four places: what extra time is worth, who pays the evaluators, whether we should wait and see, and how much the flag on the lab matters.
Team Size Is a Governance Variable
Extinction bounties, the False Claims Act, SEC whistleblower awards and antitrust leniency all rest on the same unstated premise: that the wrongdoing requires enough people that one of them can be paid to defect. That premise has a number attached, the number is falling, and no one is tracking it.
The Chilling Effect Is the Product
Everywhere else on this site the chilling effect is scored as a cost. It is worth one page arguing the opposite: it is the only output that matters, and the steady state it aims at is a world where nothing happens.